National Bank of Kenya has been ordered to pay former senior manager Kelvin Liginia Jumba Sh4.07 million after the Employment and Labour Relations Court found that his dismissal was unfair, partly because the lender withheld an investigation report he needed to defend himself.
Justice Onesmus Makau ruled on November 12, 2026, that the bank violated fair disciplinary procedures by refusing to provide the report or relevant extracts, despite relying on its findings to terminate Jumba's employment.
The court awarded him Sh3.49 million, equivalent to six months' salary, in compensation for unfair termination and a further Sh581,731 in lieu of one month's notice. The bank was also ordered to pay legal costs and interest at court rates.
Court ruling on unfair dismissal
Jumba joined the lender in June 2014 and rose to become Senior Manager, Special Projects and Partnerships in July 2022. His employment was terminated in December that year following allegations of negligence in handling invoices and engaging a business partner without the required internal approvals.
The bank accused him of delaying Nouveta Limited invoices worth Sh10.9 million for seven months, allegedly exposing the lender to financial losses. It also accused him of engaging JamboPay, owned by Webtribe Limited, without completing the necessary internal approval and procurement procedures.
Jumba disputed the allegations, arguing that the invoice delays were linked to unresolved contractual arrangements involving the bank, Nouveta and Nairobi City County. He also maintained that the proposed JamboPay partnership had received support from the bank's managing director.
Details of the allegations
During disciplinary proceedings, Jumba requested the investigation report underpinning the allegations, but the bank declined, describing it as a confidential management document. Its employee relations representative told the court that only relevant extracts could be shared with an employee facing disciplinary action.
However, the bank did not provide those extracts or produce the investigation report in court. It also failed to call the investigator or other witnesses to substantiate the allegations.
Justice Makau held that an employee must receive the information and evidence relied upon by an employer to make an effective defence. The court cited the Fair Administrative Action Act, which requires disclosure of relevant material where an administrative decision could adversely affect an individual's rights.
Legal implications of the ruling
The judge also found that the bank had not proved that Jumba negligently delayed the invoices or engaged JamboPay without approval.
The ruling reinforces the obligations imposed on employers under Kenya's Employment Act, which requires termination to be supported by valid reasons and a fair process.
For banks and other employers, the decision highlights the potential financial and legal consequences of disciplinary procedures that rely on evidence employees are not allowed to examine.









