Nairobi City County has secured a temporary reprieve from paying more than Sh2.5 billion in compensation to the owner of Ukay Mall following a Court of Appeal decision suspending enforcement of the award over the building's demolition in 2018.

A three-judge bench granted the stay after finding that paying the substantial amount before the appeal is determined could cripple the county's operations. The judges noted that the compensation would have to come from public funds, raising concerns about the potential impact on services delivered to Nairobi residents.

The dispute involves Kental Enterprises Limited, the company that owned the Westlands property, which was demolished on August 10, 2018, during a government-led crackdown on buildings alleged to have encroached on riparian land.

Background of the case

In March 2025, the Environment and Land Court ruled that the demolition violated the company's constitutional right to property and was conducted without due process. The court found that authorities had not followed the required procedures before bringing down the building.

Justice Joseph Oguttu Mboya ordered the Attorney-General, the National Environment Management Authority, the Water Resources Authority and Nairobi City County to jointly or severally pay Kental Sh2.0135 billion in compensation and Sh50 million in exemplary damages.

The awards also attract interest at 14% annually, with interest on the property compensation running from January 22, 2019, and interest on exemplary damages running from the date of the March 2025 judgment. Legal costs were also awarded to the company, pushing the potential liability beyond the principal compensation figure.

Financial implications for Nairobi County

Nairobi County subsequently challenged the judgment, arguing that enforcing the award would divert money allocated to essential services, including healthcare, education, infrastructure and waste management. It maintained that the financial burden could undermine its ability to deliver services to residents.

Kental Enterprises opposed the application, with its director Bimal Shah arguing that the company had sufficient assets to refund the money if the county ultimately succeeded in its appeal. He maintained that the company should be allowed to benefit from the judgment it had obtained.

The Court of Appeal's decision does not overturn the original compensation ruling or determine the merits of the county's appeal. It only suspends enforcement while the appellate proceedings continue.

Impact on local businesses

Ukay Mall previously housed several businesses, including Nakumatt Supermarket. Its demolition formed part of wider operations in Nairobi in 2018 targeting structures authorities said had encroached on river reserves, wetlands and public land.

The case highlights the financial exposure public agencies face when enforcement actions are found to have breached legal procedures, with any eventual compensation potentially falling on taxpayers.