Stanbic Bank Kenya has failed to stop a borrower from pursuing a lawsuit challenging his negative credit listing after the lender auctioned his Nairobi apartment to recover a Sh14.2 million loan.
The High Court dismissed the bank's application to strike out Alfred Ogalo Mango's case, finding that an earlier dispute over the auction did not settle whether the subsequent credit listing was lawful or accurate.
The dispute began with two credit facilities: a Sh7 million loan advanced in May 2018 and a further Sh7.2 million in June 2019. The loans were secured against an apartment in Nairobi.
Background of the loan dispute
Stanbic said Mango defaulted on the facilities and proceeded to exercise its statutory power of sale. The property was auctioned and transferred to a new owner in April 2023.
Mango subsequently challenged the auction and transfer, seeking to protect his occupation of the apartment. The High Court rejected his application for an injunction in September 2024, and the Court of Appeal also declined to grant temporary relief in February 2025. The substantive property dispute remains pending.
Mango later filed a separate case challenging Stanbic's decision to report him negatively to a Credit Reference Bureau (CRB). He argues that the bank listed him after selling the apartment, recovering the loan and closing his account, and that the listing was made without notice.
Stanbic opposed the fresh lawsuit, arguing that the borrower was attempting to reopen matters already considered by the courts. The lender maintained that reporting the loan information was part of its regulatory obligations and asked the court to strike out the case as an abuse of the judicial process.
However, the court found that the earlier proceedings had dealt with applications for temporary injunctions rather than a final determination of the parties' claims.
Court's findings on credit reporting
It distinguished the original dispute, which concerned ownership and possession of the apartment, from the new case, which focuses on Mango's reputation and credit standing.
The court observed that the two cases involved different causes of action and remedies, meaning the borrower could pursue the credit-reporting claim independently.
The decision leaves key questions unresolved, including whether the auction proceeds fully settled the outstanding loan and whether Stanbic had a valid basis for continuing to report Mango negatively after the sale.
Implications for credit reporting accuracy
The case highlights the importance of accurate credit reporting in Kenya's lending market, where CRB records can influence borrowers' access to loans and other financial services.
For banks, the proceedings also underline the need to ensure that information shared with credit bureaus remains accurate, properly supported and consistent with the status of a customer's outstanding obligations.
The dismissal of Stanbic's application does not amount to a finding that the lender violated credit-reporting rules. Those issues will be determined when the substantive case is heard.









