South Africa has ordered an investigation into Swimming South Africa following Olympic champion Tatjana Smith’s decision to switch sporting allegiance to the Netherlands, with Sports Minister Gayton McKenzie questioning the federation’s treatment of the country’s most decorated Olympian.
McKenzie has asked the South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (SASCOC) to conduct a full investigation into the federation following complaints by Smith over a sponsorship dispute that resulted in her prize money from the 2023 World Aquatics Championships being withheld for approximately 12 months.
Speaking during a media briefing in Cape Town on November 17, McKenzie apologised to Smith, saying her treatment by the federation was unacceptable and raised concerns about how other athletes were being handled.
Smith had earned US$35,000 after winning gold in the 200 metres breaststroke and silver in the 100 metres breaststroke at the championships held in Fukuoka, Japan, in July 2023.
However, Swimming South Africa withheld the money after a dispute involving the federation’s official sponsor, Arena, and Smith’s personal sponsor, Speedo. The swimmer had competed wearing Speedo-branded technical swimwear while representing South Africa.
According to McKenzie, the federation subsequently issued Smith with an invoice for €46,000 over what it termed an Arena sponsorship infringement. The amount was higher than the prize money she had earned at the competition.
The minister said Smith’s attempts to recover her earnings through correspondence with federation officials went unanswered, forcing her to engage lawyers in May 2024 to secure the money. Although the prize money was eventually released, the interest accrued during the delay was only paid in 2026.
McKenzie said the federation had no proper basis for withholding the earnings, adding that Smith had not signed its sponsorship agreement with Arena and had not been subjected to a disciplinary hearing before the penalty was imposed.
He also questioned why the federation’s management had allowed her to compete in the same equipment before subsequently penalising her.
Swimming South Africa has since withdrawn the fine, while its acting president, Zikie Molusi, acknowledged that the organisation’s handling of the matter was unprocedural and described Smith’s departure as an indictment on the federation.
McKenzie has asked SASCOC to establish how the Arena sponsorship agreement operates, what penalties have been imposed on swimmers, who has paid them and whether other athletes have experienced similar withholding of prize money.
The investigation will also examine expenditure at the Franschhoek High Performance Centre, weaknesses in the federation’s constitution and the reasons behind swimmers’ decisions to represent other countries. SASCOC has been asked to deploy a task team to help stabilise the organisation.
SASCOC acting head Lwandile Simelane committed to delivering the investigation report within 90 days.
McKenzie said he could not immediately dismiss the federation’s leadership, explaining that sporting bodies operate under independent governance structures and that the matter must first go through SASCOC’s processes.
The investigation comes amid wider leadership challenges at Swimming South Africa, whose president Alan Fritz and chief executive Shaun Adriaanse have been provisionally suspended by World Aquatics’ integrity unit. The suspensions are not findings of wrongdoing.
Smith announced her decision to represent the Netherlands on November 10, explaining that the move would allow her to explore her Dutch heritage while accessing greater high-performance support and building a more sustainable swimming career.
The 29-year-old holds dual citizenship and previously retired from competitive swimming in 2024 before reversing her decision this year to pursue another Olympic campaign.
She won the 200 metres breaststroke gold at the Tokyo 2020 Olympics, alongside silver in the 100 metres breaststroke, before securing another gold in the 100 metres and silver in the 200 metres at the Paris 2024 Games.
Her four Olympic medals make her South Africa’s most decorated Olympian. She is now targeting the 50 metres breaststroke title at the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics.
In his address, McKenzie questioned the message Smith’s experience could send to younger swimmers, warning that the handling of established athletes could undermine confidence in the federation.
He said the investigation was intended to establish accountability and address the administrative shortcomings affecting South African swimming, adding that reforms were necessary to prevent similar situations involving other athletes.









