The Ethics and Anti-Corruption Commission (EACC) has moved to recover Ksh.40.3 million paid to a former Kenya Rural Roads Authority (KeRRA) deputy director, accusing her of using forged academic certificates to secure employment and subsequent promotions.

In a suit filed at the High Court's Anti-Corruption and Economic Crimes Division in Nairobi, the commission wants Margaret Wanja Muthui ordered to refund Ksh.40,329,379.65 in salaries and allowances earned between October 2009 and May 2023.

The EACC is also seeking declarations that her recruitment as a procurement officer and subsequent appointment as procurement manager were fraudulent and unlawful, arguing that she relied on questionable academic qualifications to advance her career at the state agency.

Allegations of academic fraud

According to court documents, Muthui applied for the position of procurement officer in May 2009, claiming to hold a Bachelor of Science degree in Computer Science from Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology (JKUAT).

She was subsequently employed on October 7, 2009, before rising through the ranks to become a senior procurement officer and later acting procurement manager in September 2011.

In November 2013, she again presented the same academic qualification, alongside a purported Master's degree in Procurement and Logistics, when applying for the position of procurement manager. She was appointed in June 2015, with the position later reclassified as deputy director in charge of supply chain management.

The alleged academic fraud was uncovered during a verification exercise initiated following a Public Service Commission circular issued in June 2022, requiring public institutions to authenticate employees' academic credentials.

KeRRA forwarded Muthui's certificates to JKUAT for verification, but the university reportedly informed the authority that her Bachelor's degree certificate was neither genuine nor issued by the institution.

The university reiterated its findings in correspondence to the EACC in September 2023.

Following her suspension in March 2023, Muthui denied possessing the disputed JKUAT degree and instead presented a Bachelor of Business Administration degree in Procurement and Supply Chain Management, allegedly awarded by Kenya Methodist University (KeMU) in July 2008.

Investigation findings

However, the commission says its investigations established that she had never enrolled at KeMU and that the certificate was not authentic.

The EACC further questioned a letter purportedly signed by the university's Registrar of Academic Affairs, Dr. Lucy Ikiara, saying the signature on the document did not match the registrar's genuine signature.

Investigators also established discrepancies in her secondary school academic records, alleging that she attained a mean grade of C in her 1995 Kenya Certificate of Secondary Education examination, contrary to the B- grade indicated in her curriculum vitae.

Although JKUAT confirmed that it had awarded Muthui a Master's degree in Procurement and Logistics in 2012, the university's Senate subsequently approved its withdrawal on March 2, 2023, after establishing that the undergraduate qualification used to secure admission was not genuine.

KeRRA later dismissed her on May 23, 2023, following disciplinary proceedings in which the board found her culpable of forgery and presenting false documents, among other charges.

Consequences of dismissal

The EACC now argues that the Ksh.40.3 million she received during her employment constitutes proceeds of corruption or money connected to corruption, maintaining that public funds should not be retained where employment was allegedly secured through fraudulent means.

The commission wants the court to nullify her appointments, order the recovery of the entire amount and award interest at court rates from the dates the payments were made until full settlement.

It is also seeking legal costs. Muthui is yet to file her response to the civil claim.