Amnesty International has criticised plans by five European countries to deport migrants to Rwanda, warning that the arrangement could expose people to human rights violations and repeat failures witnessed in previous attempts to transfer asylum seekers to third countries.
Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands announced on November 16, 2026, that they were beginning negotiations with Rwanda to establish a migration return hub during the Vienna Migration Conference in Austria.
Under the proposed pilot project, the first group of people without the legal right to remain in the participating European Union (EU) countries is expected to be transferred to Rwanda in 2027.
In a statement published on November 17, Amnesty International’s asylum and migration expert at Amnesty International Austria, Aimée Stuflesser, described the arrangement as a repeat of failed migration policies that have exposed vulnerable people to serious abuses.
“Sending people to a country they have never been to is irresponsible. There is a real danger that the Rwanda deal, with its limited chance for scrutiny, will become a cruel black hole for human rights,” Stuflesser said.
She cited previous arrangements, including Italy’s agreement with Albania, Britain’s abandoned plan to deport asylum seekers to Rwanda and Australia’s offshore detention system, arguing that such policies had proved unlawful, unworkable and expensive.
Amnesty warned that similar schemes had resulted in serious human rights violations and damaged asylum systems. It also pointed to the EU’s past cooperation with countries such as Libya, saying the arrangements had demonstrated the bloc’s inability or unwillingness to uphold human rights despite safeguards.
Stuflesser also highlighted the significance of the announcement taking place in Vienna, where states came together in 1993 to affirm the universality of human rights, warning that those protections were now being gradually undermined.
The organisation warned that transferring migrants to Rwanda could increase the risk of refoulement, the practice of returning individuals to countries where they face persecution, torture or other serious harm.
It also raised concerns about possible onward deportations from Rwanda and the risk of torture, inhuman or degrading treatment during or after transfers.
Amnesty questioned which government would be legally responsible for protecting migrants once they leave European territory, warning that uncertainty over jurisdiction could make it difficult for victims to seek justice and obtain effective legal remedies.
The UN Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants has similarly warned that outsourcing migration control to third countries and private actors makes it harder to establish legal responsibility for human rights violations. However, such arrangements do not release governments from their human rights obligations.
Amnesty further cited Rwanda’s human rights record, including allegations of torture in detention facilities, arbitrary arrests, restrictions on freedom of expression and assembly, and the targeting of political opponents, journalists and human rights defenders.
The organisation also raised concerns over Rwanda’s alleged support for the armed group formerly known as the March 23 Movement (M23) in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo, which has been accused of serious abuses, including summary killings, gang rape and pillage.
The latest initiative follows Britain’s attempt to establish a similar arrangement, which was ruled unlawful by the UK Supreme Court in 2023.
The court found substantial grounds for believing that asylum seekers transferred to Rwanda faced a real risk of being returned to countries where they could suffer persecution, violating the principle of non-refoulement.
However, unlike Britain’s proposal, which involved transferring asylum seekers to Rwanda for their claims to be processed, the new European arrangement targets people whose applications have already been rejected.
The participating governments maintain that the proposed return hubs will comply with international human rights standards. The EU’s new Return Regulation also permits deportation centres in non-EU countries only where international human rights standards are respected.
Amnesty has called on Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands to withdraw from the proposed arrangement.









